Full Version | Mobile Edition
State Journal Home
Featured Links | Local Job Listings | Who's Who 2009 Winners | West Virginia Legislature | Future of Energy Forum
HOME |  UPFRONT |  GOVERNMENT |  YOUR BUSINESS |  LAW |  OPINION |  DECISION MAKERS |  WV TONIGHT LIVE |  NOMINATIONS  |  EVENTS  |  MEDIA GUIDE  |  ABOUT US  |  ADVERTISE
  Where to Buy  |  Subscribe Now
Renew Subscription
Change Delivery Address

Home > News

Print this story RSS
 
Lowdown on Lists
Posted Thursday, October 29, 2009 ; 06:00 AM | View Comments | Post Comment
Updated Friday, October 30, 2009; 10:26 AM


Rankings paint state in bad light; so how does it fight that image?

Story by Walt Williams
Email | Other Stories by Walt Williams

Got bad news for you, West Virginia.

You're fat, out-of-shape, unhygienic, diabetic, depressed, disabled, over-taxed, over-regulated, over-litigated, over-medicated, uneducated, unskilled, child-abusing, child-neglecting and generally dirt poor.

You're ugly if you're a guy from Huntington. You sure know how to party if you're from Morgantown. And you're inbred no matter where you're from, according to the wisdom of a former vice president.

The above is the charming image anyone would take away if all he or she knew about West Virginia came from media stories, rankings and surveys. The state usually ranks last in polls it wants to rank first in and first in polls it wants to rank last. All in all, it adds up to a lot of bad publicity for the Mountain State.

How seriously can these reports be taken? In some cases, there really is fire where there's smoke, particularly with regard to health data. But others could be as much opinion as fact, and sometimes the organizations that produce them won't disclose just how they reached their conclusions.

Whatever the case, it has state officials on perpetual damage control.

"I hate the connotations and the perceptions that are out there, and we're fighting that every day," Gov. Joe Manchin said.

These days it seems a lot of people are bad-mouthing West Virginia. Forbes.com declared it one of the worst states in which to do business, as well as the state with the dirtiest environment. Business groups have labeled it a "judicial hellhole," where it is far too easy for trial lawyers to win large settlements for clients. Unions continue to point out it ranks near the bottom in terms of teacher and state employee pay.

The Princeton Review ranks West Virginia University as one of the top "party schools" in the nation, an unflattering ranking given to those institutions where students allegedly spend little time studying.

Most recently, the women's Web site TotalBeauty.com ranked Huntington as having some of the ugliest men in the nation, a conclusion reached in part on erotic entertainment sales in the city. ("No sex generally equals less hot guys," the authors claimed.)

Some of the above examples will never be accused of being scientific. However, there is plenty of credible data painting a grim picture of the state.

West Virginia is last in the nation in the percentage of college graduates, according to U.S. Census Bureau figures. It's one of the most obese states in the nation. It leads in the number of diabetics, disabilities and people using and abusing prescription drugs. Its citizens' dental health is among the poorest in the nation. And a recent study concluded there were more cases of substantiated child abuse and neglect in West Virginia than most other states.

Tying them all together is the fact West Virginia is exceptionally poor, with only Mississippi families earning lower median incomes, according to the Census.

All that data points to real problems that people interviewed for this story said need to be addressed. But they also see focusing only on the negatives as a distraction from what they said are the state's many positives -- from its generally good quality of life to its relatively cheap cost of living.

"What I always recommend to a crisis client is you have to go out on the offense; you can't go on the defense," said Patrick Gallagher, CEO of Charles Ryan Associates, a public relations firm headquartered in Charleston.

Gallagher can't say whether the negative publicity has had any impact on the state in terms of attracting businesses, but he recounted his own experience in dealing with clients who had only driven through the state in the past. Once they had the chance to spend some time in West Virginia, they liked what they saw.

That's why he recommends winning people over by giving them firsthand experience with the Mountain State. It's a strategy also suggested by George Manahan of the Manahan Group, a public relations firm in Charleston. He would match out-of-state business people with people who already do business here so they could hear from someone about what West Virginia is like.

"Unless you had a good experience, or know someone who had a good experience and can tell you about it, those negative polls and statements can hurt the state," Manahan said.

Manchin also pointed to personal experience as key for improving the state's image. He noted Steve Forbes' recent visit to the state and the opportunity it provided local officials and business people to make their case against some of the portrayals of West Virginia in his publications.

"I take constructive criticism very well," Manchin said, adding he has contacted media outlets and other organizations when they have put out information portraying the state in a negative light.

"But I want you to be factual and accurate when you talk about us."

Copyright 2010 West Virginia Media. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Most Popular Stories on STATEJOURNAL.com Most Discussed Stories on STATEJOURNAL.com

User Comments [ post comment ]
User Comment
Griffin
11/2/09 at 12:37 PM
Report Abuse
First of all, West Virginians need to stop focusing on fighting the image and get down to the basics of real change. Before we can worry about bringing others to our state, we need to make it a good place for the West Virginians who are still living there. My family and I left back in 2006, after hanging grimly on by our fingernails for the five years before that. We couldn't live with both of us working, but now, out west, I am able to stay home with the kids while my husband works. The kids are happier. We are doing great. I'm homesick, but I don't see us coming back anytime soon. Better to be homesick and have a good life, than be home and starve.
User Comment
BrianB
11/2/09 at 9:15 AM
Report Abuse
I am one of the very many natives forced to leave for a better opportunity. I always return to read articles like Walt's. There is nothing new here- this article could be dated 1989 just as easily as 2009. For years a pall has rested over this state. West Virginia could change, but it would require a level of self examination and acceptance that people here are uncomfortable with. They tend to puff up in self defense, like a school yard bully, quick to point the finger in the wrong direction. First, is WV interested in change? If so, then an impartial and detailed assessment is over due. Questions of diversity (not just in business), equality, and opportunity need to be addressed: What are we doing wrong? What are we doing right? Are we paying too much attention to one industry at the expense of all others? How can we build partnerships with out of state institutions and companies? How do we build a cross cultural dialogue and it not be just lip service?

When these questions are finally tackled and action groups and politicians desire true and abiding change, then and only then will WV possibily no longer be at sea.

User Comment
Concerned Mountaineer
11/1/09 at 8:09 PM
Report Abuse
Must be a slow news day. This reporter has nothing else to cover? Its been like this for 50 years or more. All the problems we have are brought on by ourselves. Where do I begin? Lets take one issue, for example. Gov. Manchin, I'm sure was trying to help out the state by changing the entrance signs to "Open for Business". But are you kidding me? Until the legislature can stop its awful horrible practice of taxing the life out of its people and what little business is here, this will never change. Ever try to start a business here? Don't! And everybody is sueing someone, especially big business. With the low cost of living, lower average wages for workers, cheap land, close proximity to half the population of the US, etc... people and business should be flocking to West Virginia. But why aren't they? Something at the Capitol isn't working. It's disheartening to go on vacation sometimes. Drove to Mobile, AL, one time. Passed two new highrises in Nashville, just south passed a new 15 story huge Toyota building, just south of Montgomery, AL, passed a new huge Coke bottling plant on the right and the new Hyundai plant on the left. Every city and state you travel thruogh shows signs of growth and advancement. Why isn't that happening here. Hyundai could have come here. FEDEX could have come here instead of Memphis. UPS could have come here instead of Louisville. Kia, here instead of Georgia. Can you believe we only have one Fortune 500 company located here? United Bank. But how many are located in Pittsburgh, Columbus, Cincy, Cleveland, Charlotte, etc. None in Huntington? Beckley? Clarksburg? I have to stop. This subject just gets me going. I guess we get what we pay for and who we vote for. Lets vote in the same people thats been in there time and time again.

Post Your Comments
All fields are Required
Name: 
Email: 
  A valid email address is required to allow State Journal to monitor comments and track users posting inappropriate comments. State Journal does not use these for any type of SPAM operation.
Comments: 
Security Code: 
Enter the code exactly as you see it above.

NOTE: You may refresh the page to load a new Confirmation Code if this one is unreadable.
 
I have read and agree to the JOURNAL Commenting Policy
NOTE: It is unlawful to disclose personal information, including names, of minors under 18 involved in any criminal action.
 



© West Virginia Media Holdings, LLC
WBOY-TV I WOWK-TV I WTRF-TV I WVNS-TV I Your ABC I ABC Ohio Valley
FOX Ohio Valley | FOX WV | The State Journal | Country Roads Journal
Closed Captioning Issues? | Public File | Privacy Policy


Site Development and Hosting By Citynet
Citynet