Full Version | Mobile Edition
State Journal Home
SJ Mobile News App |Featured Links | 2010 Generation Next Winners | West Virginia Legislature | State Journal List Central
HOME |  UPFRONT |  GOVERNMENT |  YOUR BUSINESS |  LAW |  OPINION |  DECISION MAKERS |  WV TONIGHT LIVE |  NOMINATIONS  |  EVENTS  |  MEDIA GUIDE  |  ABOUT US  |  ADVERTISE
  Where to Buy  |  Subscribe Now
Renew Subscription
Change Delivery Address

Home > News

Print this story RSS
Morgantown Murderer Subject of True Crime Novel
Posted Thursday, March 11, 2010 ; 06:47 PM | View Comments | Post Comment
Updated Thursday, March 11, 2010; 07:12 PM


Michelle Michael
Photo Credit: West Virginia Division of Corrections
Michelle Michael was convicted of murdering her husband, James.

By Jessika Lewis
Email | Bio | Other Stories by Jessika Lewis

MORGANTOWN -- True crime author John Glatt has released a novel about convicted Morgantown murderer Michelle Michael.

Published on March 2, Glatt’s book "Playing with Fire" profiles the story surrounding the murder of James Michael, Michelle’s husband.

Glatt said he was intrigued by the story after seeing coverage on news program "48 Hours," and began writing the novel after meeting with Michael at the Lakin Correctional Center in late January 2009.

Michael is there serving a life sentence with mercy for murder plus 20 years for arson, because she injected her husband, James, with a paralyzing drug, then set fire to the couple’s Killarney Drive home.

James died in that fire, but Michelle Michael still claims she did not kill him.

Related Links:
   - John Glatt's Web Site

Copyright 2010 West Virginia Media. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Most Popular Stories on STATEJOURNAL.com Most Discussed Stories on STATEJOURNAL.com

User Comments [ post comment ]
User Comment
The REAL story
4/21/10 at 12:19 PM
Report Abuse
Michelle did talk to the author and NO she did not agree to the book but pleaded with him not to write it and NO she is not making anything on ANY publication. She was wrongly convicted but is not intitled to make any money either. I would like to talk more with Preston to get more of his views. There is a lot more to this case than meets the eye and the truth will come out that she is INNOCENT!!!!
User Comment
Sparky
3/22/10 at 12:48 PM
Report Abuse
You are the only one to think that, Preston......
User Comment
preston
3/20/10 at 8:48 AM
Report Abuse
OK i have to ask.....you say everyone thinks I am insane...is it because I think she is innocent, or because of all the postings, which i will admit are excessive but I want someone else to finally agree that she could be innocent. If I am the only one...then maybe I should rethink my view.
User Comment
WOW
3/19/10 at 2:37 PM
Report Abuse
Anyone that keeps saying stuff about large people is large themselves.. There is nothing wrong with people that are large... This Killer is nothing but that a killer...Preston you are just a sad old sole looking for a thrill... I am starting to think along with everyone else that you had a hand in this killing... Maybe we should contact the police and have you looked into.. All they have to do is contact WBOY and get your email address...Its rather simple to do... So keep making your comments because every other person if not all of us besides you think you are insane...
User Comment
preston
3/19/10 at 2:00 PM
Report Abuse
To me, no i do not know who those people are. To concerned, where is the Blue Moose....I despise weirdos, so many in Morgantown. To wow...sore spot, you must be rather large....drop that doughnut

MY REASONS TO THINK SHE MAY BE INNOCENT

1. THE EX'S BOTH DATED 2. WHERE WAS ONE EX, AT HOME WITH A BABY????? 3. THE DRUG IN QUESTION COULD BE ORDERED ONLINE ACCORDING TO HER ATTORNEY. 4. WHO HAD THE TIP CALLED IN ORIGINALLY CAME FROM HER EX SISTER IN LAW...WHO ALSO HAD ACCESS TO IT. THOSE ARE ENOUGH REASONS FOR REASONABLE DOUBT

I AM NOT SAYING ANYONE COMMITTED THIS CRIME JUST SAYING IT SHOULD BE ENOUGH FOR REASONABLE DOUBT.
User Comment
Me
3/19/10 at 12:14 PM
Report Abuse
Preston - Are you Gary or Priscella?
User Comment
Concerned
3/18/10 at 5:14 PM
Report Abuse
Preston - why are you so sure she's innocent? Please prove beyond a reasonable doubt, maybe we can understand where you're coming from.

Are you one of the weirdos that hang out at Blue Moose all day and think they're cool?
User Comment
WOW
3/18/10 at 4:29 PM
Report Abuse
Preston two words for you PATHEIC LOSER....
User Comment
preston
3/18/10 at 3:47 PM
Report Abuse
I am not female......you must be one of those large women who are jealous of the thin pretty cheerleader type..ALSO. I am putting it out there, that she may be innocent, yes she was wrongfully found guilty. but her innocence will be proven. BTW I work in morgantown everyday......just look for me and my laptop...hehe I am not hard to miss.
User Comment
SERIOUSLY??
3/18/10 at 1:02 PM
Report Abuse
I think Preston is Michelle! A lot of these women's prisons are not all that tied down and strict. Look at Martha Stewart.... She could be on the computer at times during the day. I know a fed ex driver that delivered a tv and xbox to a man in prison. He got his income tax check back and ordered this stuff online. Preston sure does have a lot of concern over someone "she has never met and didn't go to the trial". A little CRAZY about proving her innocence if you ask me. MICHELLE IS GUILTY AS CHARGED!!!!!!!
User Comment
preston
3/18/10 at 7:25 AM
Report Abuse
No i am still here....concerned sounds like you are not SURE she did it....when then that is reasonable doubt and she should not be in prison then.....and she is attractive... i love how most "large" women are jealous of something they can never be....100pds.
User Comment
WOW
3/17/10 at 10:27 PM
Report Abuse
Concerned I think you hit a sore spot with preston... Maybe that will shut him/her up...
User Comment
Concerned
3/17/10 at 9:19 PM
Report Abuse
Preston, I'm still leaning toward the possibility that you did it...I've never known a "supporter" to defend someone in as much detail. It's almost as if you are not mentally stable,you have stalked her for years, maybe even worked with her and when you figured out she wasn't leaving her husband, you decided to get her attention by getting him out of the way. Am I close? You are seriously making people wonder...If that is not the scenario, then did she hire you to do it? Is that how you can be so sure?

BTW, she is not pretty, I do not understand why people keep saying that, maybe because she's 100lbs and everyone around here's used to 200lb women? Anyway, whoever says she's pretty has low to moderate taste.
User Comment
WOW
3/17/10 at 6:33 PM
Report Abuse
Who is jealous of a cold hearted killer???? Preston you are something else.... I think your mind is just as warped as hers...
User Comment
preston
3/17/10 at 5:43 PM
Report Abuse
in response....i don't have alot of time on my hands.....i keep up my posts from work. and anyone who wants to know where to buy the book, any book store will have the copies. She is a beautiful woman...so much jealousy because of her picture...WOW
User Comment
WOW
3/17/10 at 3:58 PM
Report Abuse
I think Preston is a stalker...He/she is totally to invovled with this case...And Preston has to much time on his or her hands to sit around all day and make post on here.. Maybe you should get off your bum and get a life...
User Comment
Sparky
3/17/10 at 3:46 PM
Report Abuse
Seriously, she was being convicted of murdering her husband in cold blood and all she could worry about during her mug shot was "keeping up her appearance"?? HA!

I am anxious to read the book....anyone know a place local (Harrison County) to get one? Not that I think she is innocent (far from that thought) but I have always been interested in crime novels.
User Comment
preston
3/17/10 at 3:17 PM
Report Abuse
well to be exact she in appealing her conviction, which I am almost certain will be overturned. these twelve people should be ashamed of themselves for sending an innocent woman to prison...how can anyone say she is guilty did you see her through the window perhaps injecting him or setting the room on fire...I think not all she was convicted on was speculation and hearsay. She may have lied and cheated....but just because she cheated doesn't make her a killer.....hell people have been cheating for years yet are not killers.
User Comment
Mon County Resident
3/17/10 at 2:46 PM
Report Abuse
Preston, get over your self and quit making excuses for a murderer. Every one is entitled to their opinion, and the fact of the matter is that twelve people, whose opinion counted when it mattered, found her guilty. Believe what you want, she was found guilty and should pay the price for what she did.
User Comment
preston
3/17/10 at 1:56 PM
Report Abuse
I think that she is smiling because.....she was always concerned about appearance and looking nice....so it would be her nature to smile for a camera. I can't say for sure...but I would think that would be the reason
User Comment
Sparky
3/17/10 at 11:48 AM
Report Abuse
In my opinion, if she truly was not guilty, then why is she smiling in her mug shot (shown above) at the prison? Sorry but that look she is giving, to me, does not look like she is very mentally stable. And she was a nurse? That's even scarier.....
User Comment
preston
3/16/10 at 1:39 PM
Report Abuse
to me....that is correct I have never met her and i was not in the courtroom..all I know is what I have read in online research. The book on the other hand...i have not read...but it says the writer interviewed her so I think she may have taken it as a opportunity to share her side. And yes, no matter what anyone's opinion is it really does not matter the only opinion that matters right now is the appellate court. Sometimes people just have to agree to disagree.
User Comment
Me
3/16/10 at 9:49 AM
Report Abuse
Preston - didn't you say in an earlier post that you can't wait to meet her? So you've never met her either. Unless you were in that Courtroom, you do not know what was said or shown from either side.

Another sign she's guilty? Why would you want a book written about YOU murdering your husband? If it were me and I was the one wrongly convicted, I would be appalled at the thought that someone wanted to make money off of my husband's murder. Just saying....

Continue with your opinion as I will continue with mine. Either way I think we can agree our opinions will not change anything right now.
User Comment
preston
3/16/10 at 12:47 AM
Report Abuse
I believe she is an innocent woman, I do not care how much anyone attacks me. I will continue to voice my opinions on how I think she was wrongfully convicted. I am told to do my research believe me I have there are many sites where flaws are pointed out in her defense. She should have gotten off, an opinion shared by many people in Morgantown the day she was convicted. By the way as I write this response I wonder how so many people can judge Michelle when most people probably never have even met her before. I sit back and pray to God that justice will be served for her and she will be released. I can't stand the thought of an innocent person sitting behind bars.
User Comment
Me
3/15/10 at 11:48 PM
Report Abuse
Okay first off, the jurors were not idiots....have you ever served on a jury? Trust me, idiots cannot serve on juries. Second, her lawyer was not an idiot, I know who it was and BTW he is ranked the best criminal defense attorney in Morgantown. The sad part of it is, when you're guilty, you're guilty. Jesus can't even save you there. Third, it is a FICTION BOOK BASED ON TRUE EVENTS YOU IDIOTS!!! You cannot believe everything it says. Only parts of it are true, the author met with the Monster so anything in there is what SHE SAYS happened, it does not mean it's all true.

Preston - you're really worrying me, how do you know she is innocent, did you really do it? You are more foolish than anyone else posting on here, to believe just because she was a nurse she must be innocent. Seriously? I doubt you have any degree....Not even a degree of common sense. She is not innocent...and it was more than a couple lies - take for instance the fact that she was intimate with a married man with her child sleeping in the other room. Yeah, GOOD people do NOT do that....Don't believe me? Research a juror's journal of the trial, you'll find exactly what I'm talking about. You were not in that courtroom, you did not experience the lack of emotion or remorse. Do not stick up for the monster unless you want to be attacked along with her. And her attorney did NOT tell her to not show emotion. DUH!!!

The best decision the jury made was life with mercy, because as one juror said, it's more misery when you THINK you will see the outside again....Life is definitly unfair, knowing she is still breathing while that man suffered, worse than anyone alive can imagine, may his family be strong and my prayers are with you.

I do know if I were one of her children, I would not admit to that...
User Comment
preston
3/15/10 at 10:30 PM
Report Abuse
It took the professionals 5 times to get the fire tweaked right and it took a cheerleader only once? Like she did it.....come on people
User Comment
preston
3/15/10 at 9:18 PM
Report Abuse
MICHELLE MICHAEL IS INNOCENT.MICHELLE MICHAEL IS INNOCENT.MICHELLE MICHAEL IS INNOCENT.MICHELLE MICHAEL IS INNOCENT.MICHELLE MICHAEL IS INNOCENT.MICHELLE MICHAEL IS INNOCENT.MICHELLE MICHAEL IS INNOCENT. need I say more
User Comment
To Preston
3/15/10 at 7:16 PM
Report Abuse
Once again that you so much for a good laugh. Is that gated community that you are living in could that be a prison???LOL You are a sad person. We will see who is laughing when she doesnt get out of prison... ANd I can say THank GOD I dont know this peice of trash...As for you I am done with you , you are a worthless peice of crap.. And I am sure you are some nice looking peice of trash yourself..
User Comment
preston
3/15/10 at 5:03 PM
Report Abuse
FACE THE FACTS SHE IS INNOCENT AND SHE WILL BE SET FREE. I am SO sure you are living the wonderful life........yeah right. Seems that maybe you knew Michelle and you were so jealous of her. You are not and probably never will be as thin and attractive as her. People like you who resort to name calling............which yes i am guilty to responding in the same way, have no facts to prove their point, so they attack. Read her book and acknowledge her account. and that is where i base my opinion.
User Comment
To Preston
3/15/10 at 2:04 PM
Report Abuse
Thanks for the laugh... People like you are nothing but TRASH... And yeah I am on welfare and live in a trailer park.. You got me...LOL.. I will let trash like you think what ever you want of me because you are nothing to me...I am living the wonderful life and I can say I dont have to worry about living behind bars or living the trashy life you are living.. So say what you want about me I know who I am and I know I am better then you ever will be...
User Comment
preston
3/15/10 at 1:34 PM
Report Abuse
for "to preston" you are so uneducated. I stand by my statement also, that you are probably paid minimum wage and are on welfare. Let me dream of where you live.....I see a trailer park. God No I cant dream of that. I look out my home by the way which is in a gated community and think you should dream of my home.
User Comment
ok people
3/15/10 at 8:37 AM
Report Abuse
I read the book, and was surprised by the fact her (x sister-in-law) old boss suggested the check for the paralytic drug, her ex, his ex had a relationship, what a tangled web. The most surprising was that her ex lawyer (prob the reason shes where she is) said he represented a crime boss? Who might that have been, & he represented hundreds of murderers? R U kidding me? I'd like to see that list. The Morgantown lawyer, had me impressed what a shame he was let go there is a skilled attorney. People are wrongfully convicted all the time we'll see how this transpires
User Comment
To Preston
3/15/10 at 6:40 AM
Report Abuse
I stand by my statement you are a COMPLETE IDIOT.. AND SHE IS NOTHING BUT TRASH....Maybe one day you will meet her in prison , trash runs with trash....And as for the minimum paid job I am laughing my butt off because you have no idea who I am and you could only dream of where I live....
User Comment
preston
3/14/10 at 11:56 PM
Report Abuse
By calling her a piece of trash, you make yourself look foolish. Michelle was a nurse, she had a Masters Degree was very active in her community. Now you call me an idiot, this only shows that is what you are. Shouldn't you get to bed instead of insulting me so you can get up and go to your minimum wage job in the morning. READ ALL MY POSTS I HAVE NEVER MET MICHELLE MICHALE ALTHOUGH I WOULD LOVE TO ONE DAY WHEN SHE IS RELEASED FROM PRISON. I will not insult you by calling you names, that is something only uneducated people do.
User Comment
To Preston
3/14/10 at 10:59 PM
Report Abuse
Preston you are a complete idiot who cares what kind of degree you have ....You must be a family member... The stupid MONSTER is where she belongs...I hope she ROTS like the trash she is...
User Comment
preston
3/14/10 at 9:38 PM
Report Abuse
I am embarrassed of the errors in my last post, computer issues. The only reason she is in prison, is because of the jury. Her lawyer presented her cases in an unflattering way, by telling her to show no emotion. She will be proven innocent. Then I will be able to tell you all I TOLD YOU SO.
User Comment
preston
3/14/10 at 8:26 PM
Report Abuse
LIKE I WROTE IN ANOTHER POST SHE IS IN PRISON BECAUSE OF A BUNCH OF THE JURY....IF THE HAD ANY COMMON SENSE SHE WOULD BE FREE TODAY....WE WILL BE PROVEN INNOCENT ONE DAY. AND I AM NOT SICK I HAVE A MASTERS DEGREE.....WHAT DO YOU HAVE. YOU PROBABLY NEVER FINISHED HIGH SCHOOL BECAUSE ANYONE THAT DID WOULD BE ABLE TO FIGURE OUT SHE IS INNOCENT
User Comment
Donna Stewart
3/13/10 at 5:22 PM
Report Abuse
I have a good friend @ Lakin Correction & it's she says it's like being on a long vacation,she gets to train Dogs & even keeps them with her in her Dorm yeah Dorm not a cell.they even have Diningrooms instead of chow halls. Michelle's no doubt living it up...what kinda punishment is that?
User Comment
what is your alls problem
3/13/10 at 12:07 PM
Report Abuse
This piece of trash is guilty...SHe is nothing but a murderer plain and simple...For all of you that think she is innocent you are just as sick as she is...So make all the rude comments you want to me because you all mean nothing to me... SHe is not in prison for nothing...
User Comment
Townie
3/13/10 at 10:39 AM
Report Abuse
Well I of course have no idea if she really was guilty or not, but I bought the book yesterday and it's really good. It puts aspects of each others life into perspective, like how truly messed up there relationship was and their previous relationships. No surprise to me that she more-than-likely is guilty.
User Comment
copied and pasted because this was a very comment on an eariler story...FREE MICHELLE.
3/13/10 at 9:37 AM
Report Abuse
marisol 1/24/10 at 6:25 PM Report Abuse Hi, I have several problems with how the investigation was completed: Namely:

1. The police gave a falsified statement of the ex-wife having an alibi. Apparently, he was using the act of being married and having a new life as an alibi itself. He lied and said that the New Husband gave the ex-wife an alibi, only after he got caught, and after issuing many previous statements in which the new husband as an alibi was never mentioned.

2. The cop further went to to give another false alibi statement to cover up for the ex'wife's lack of an aliby. He stated that the act of havnig an infact in the premises in itself was an alibi. Those of us who are parents know that once you feed your baby, burp him and put him to sleep. It would be another couple of hours before that baby would start crying again. Apparently.

3. The phone call. The police had received a phone call from an anonymous third party telling them of the medication that was used to drug the husband. Af of the mid 90's we have had the technology readily availabe to law enforcement to tract all phone calls including those from pre-paid cell phones, and to use signal triangulation to even poinpoint which intersection the call came in from. The fact that the phone call was withheld from the judge and the jury, in itself is a red flag. It points that the police were actually active in covering up a murder just to blame that easiest target, because Michelle was not very well liked.

3. The car: The gps in the car would have recorded the exact route that the car took. This technology has been available since the early 90's. The police was taking advantage that the general public did not have access to this information hoping to get the general public against the suspect Michelle. Basically, I believe that this was done in order to taint the general public and, subsequently the jury pool before the trial even began. Saying that the car took off in a general direction was what used to be used in criminal cases back in the late 80's, but it stopped in the 90's.

4. Yes, michelle did lie a bunch of times, but there were basically only two lies, (1) she lied that she left to take care of an errand becasue she did not want to get into trouble with her job, (2), she lied of the affair that she had.

I'm not taking sides here, except that to say that in NYC we have one of the countries best forensice (CSI) scientists and I learned from him, he is one of the best.
User Comment
preston
3/13/10 at 9:28 AM
Report Abuse
sorry i meant to type idiots because that is what they were....how can they live with themselves
User Comment
preston
3/13/10 at 9:24 AM
Report Abuse
She has every right to tell HER story. If she profits from it....good for her. I feel she should not have been sent to prison, the jury that day must have been made up of complete idots. She is innocent and this will be proven one day..BY THE WAY I am not related to Michelle nor have I even met her....I just followed the story....dominion post, television specials..ect. there is alot of support for Michelle.........there use to be a website something like justice for michelle....check it out...
User Comment
grandma
3/12/10 at 1:09 PM
Report Abuse
this killer does not deserve another trial let alone a book written about the terrible crime she did and she should never get a penny from it, how absurd. i hope she never sees the light of day. god be with james michaels family who has to live with this and the loss everyday of their lives, this killer is still breathing which is too much for her.
User Comment
makin$nprison
3/12/10 at 11:08 AM
Report Abuse
I think it is horrible that she is probably getting a cut off of the book deal....so she is making money while in prison for killing her husband...Also the rumor is that she appealed her conviction and won so she is suppose to get a new trial...Which really sucks..., because she did it, she knows she did it no live with it..instead of wasting our taxpayers money for a new trial.
User Comment
FRIEND OF JIM
3/12/10 at 8:54 AM
Report Abuse
Jim was a friendly nice outgoing guy who never met a stranger . I have spoken with some of his co-workers and they all agreed . I feel life with is to easy for her , since WV does not have the death penalty at least she should get life without it was all permeditated on her part........
User Comment
Mon County resident
3/12/10 at 7:24 AM
Report Abuse
I can't believe this murderer is still getting press time of any kind, good or bad. She murdered a good man, and then tried to go after his life insurance money to take it away from his children. Let her rot in prison where she belongs!
User Comment
cjs student
3/12/10 at 1:35 AM
Report Abuse
oh im sure shes loving every minute of being locked up with book deal. its people like her that make me wish wv still had the death penalty...and i don't mean no needle in the arm either...
User Comment
kr
3/11/10 at 8:45 PM
Report Abuse
I was hoping we had heard the last of this killer.
User Comment
she is something else
3/11/10 at 8:29 PM
Report Abuse
I bet she isnt smiling in prison...LOL...

Post Your Comments
All fields are Required
Name: 
Email: 
  A valid email address is required to allow State Journal to monitor comments and track users posting inappropriate comments. State Journal does not use these for any type of SPAM operation.
Comments: 
Security Code: 
Enter the code exactly as you see it above.

NOTE: You may refresh the page to load a new Confirmation Code if this one is unreadable.
 
I have read and agree to the JOURNAL Commenting Policy
NOTE: It is unlawful to disclose personal information, including names, of minors under 18 involved in any criminal action.
 



© West Virginia Media Holdings, LLC
WBOY-TV I WOWK-TV I WTRF-TV I WVNS-TV I Your ABC I ABC Ohio Valley
FOX Ohio Valley | FOX WV | The State Journal | Country Roads Journal
Closed Captioning Issues? | Public File | Privacy Policy


Site Development and Hosting By Citynet
Citynet